The Allstate Sugar Bowl recognized an outstanding high school athlete from the state of Louisiana from 1968 to 2007. Any high school athletes competing in Louisiana were eligible for the honor. The winners were selected by the Greater New Orleans Sports Awards Committee, which has been existence since 1957. All of the
Sugar Bowl annual awards were presented on a calendar-year basis until 2009 when the Committee changed to an academic calendar (July-June). Records from 1991-98 are not available.
Outstanding Prep Athlete, State of Louisiana (1968-2007)
- 2007: Ashley Brignac, John Curtis H.S. Softball
- 2006: Joe McKnight, John Curtis H.S. Football
- 2004: Ryan Perrilloux, East St. John H.S. Football
- 2003: Chris Markey, Jesuit H.S. Football
- 2002: Meghan O’Leary, Baton Rouge Episcopal H.S. Basketball, Volleyball & Softball
- 2001: Skyler Higgins, Higgins H.S. Football
- 2000: Chris Duhon, Slidell H.S. Basketball
- 1999: Brock Berlin, Evangel Christian Academy Football
- 1990: Duane Spencer, Cohen H.S. Basketball
- 1988: Brad Banta, University H.S. Football
- 1987: Tyrone Hughes, St. Augustine H.S. Football
- 1986: Mickey Joseph, Archbishop Shaw H.S. Football
- 1985: Warde Manuel, Brother Martin H.S. Football
- 1984: John White, Country Day School Football
- 1983: Tookie Spann, Brother Martin H.S. Football/Baseball
- 1982: Benoit Benjamin, Carroll H.S. Basketball
- 1981: Garry James, West Jefferson H.S. Football
- 1980: Bobby Joe Douglas, Marion (Lake Charles) H.S. Boys Basketball
- 1979: Bobby Beck, Salmen H.S. Track & Field
- 1978: Alan Risher, Salmen H.S. Football
- 1977: NA
- 1976: NA
- 1975: Larry Wilson, South Lafourche H.S. Basketball
- 1974: Rick Robey, Brother Martin H.S. Basketball
- 1973: Carlos Pennywell, Captain Shreve H.S. Football
- 1972: Terry Robiskie, Second Ward H.S. (Edgard, La.) Football
- 1971: Louis Dunbar, Webster H.S. (Minden, La.) Basketball
- 1970: Mike Miley, East Jefferson H.S. Football
- 1969: Tyler Lafauci, De La Salle H.S. Football
- 1968: Joe Ferguson, Woodlawn H.S. (Shreveport, La.) Football