The Allstate Sugar Bowl recognized an outstanding sports organization from the Greater New Orleans area from 1958 to 1990, though only in years when it was determined there was a highly qualified organization. The winners were selected by the Greater New Orleans Sports Awards Committee, which has been existence since 1957. All of the
Sugar Bowl annual awards were presented on a calendar-year basis until 2009 when the Committee changed to an academic calendar (July-June).
Outstanding Sports Organization, Greater New Orleans (no longer awarded)
- 1986: New Orleans Times-Picayune & Coca-Cola
- 1982: We Care
- 1981: Greater New Orleans Athletic League
- 1980: Nehemiah Atkinson Tennis Foundation
- 1975: Italian Open
- 1974: Louisiana Superdome Baseball Committee
- 1973: New Orleans Midwinter Sports Association
- 1972: Louisiana Superdome Baseball Committee
- 1971: None
- 1970: None
- 1969: Super Bowl Task Force – George W. Healey, Chairman
- 1968: New Orleans Athletic Club
- 1967: New Orleans Recreation Department
- 1966: New Orleans Women’s Bowling Association
- 1965: New Orleans Midwinter Sports Association
- 1964: New Orleans Football Club – David Dixon, President
- 1963: Catholic Youth Organization
- 1962: Westbank Lions Club
- 1961: Greater New Orleans Open Golf Tournament
- 1960: New Orleans Midwinter Sports Association
- 1959: St. Mary’s CYO
